WARMINGTON: Does changing CFL rules take 'Canada' out of our game?

· Toronto Sun

See more Toronto Sun on Google — save as a Preferred Source

Canada does not want to become America’s 51st state — or see their style of football replace the more exciting Canadian brand either.

Visit likesport.biz for more information.

Like the Snowbirds, whose last performance was at this year’s 113th Grey Cup in Calgary, we don’t want to see the great Canadian game go extinct, either.

So when they shrink the length of the CFL field next season to what the NFL plays on, will it still be the Canadian game? When you combine making the end zones smaller and taking out the centre line, which will make the field 10 yards shorter than what it has been all our lives, it does feel like they are taking the ‘Canada’ out of football as we know it.

But a Toronto Argos employee begged to differ on that point. And he pushed back on me for suggesting it on X. In an X post of his own, Argos communications manager and talented play-by-play man Mike Hogan strongly defended the move, which takes effect next season.

“Three downs, 12 players, the waggle, no fair catch, 65-yard wide field, 20-second clock after the three-minute warning, Canadian player ratio, normal kickoffs, 50% bigger end zones, a yard off the ball, overtime shootouts. Sounds pretty Canadian to me.”

It seems to be a hot button.

Argos calling me out

But it was my post saying “the CFL game was perfect for 113 years” and “it’s no longer Canadian football” that seemed to hit a sore spot.

“Just calling you out on your initial post,” Hogan wrote on X.

In the same posted, he also wrote “the game is still distinctly Canadian, which your initial post disputed. People got upset at the game clock and rouge changes last year and both have made the game better IMO (in my opinion).”

I didn’t mean to hurt anyone’s feelings. Or push an agenda. I was just sharing my view on it. That said, in his retort, Hogan made some good points I hadn’t considered and am prepared to take a second look at. Maybe a bunch of us were thinking the worst and jumping to conclusions before there is proper evidence?

Also, perhaps with so many Canucks not supporting the CFL like they certainly did when we were growing up in a different era, there’s nothing wrong with the league’s commissioner Stewart Johnston trying to do something new and different.

Should CFL fans be open to change?

The problem is I liked it the way it has always been. As veteran Calgary sports journalist Lisa Bowes said on X “why fix what ain’t broke?”

Proponents of these changes would argue the economics of the CFL are broken and in need of some upgrading. Will making the field smaller, putting the goal posts to the back of the end zone, getting rid of the return or giving up a single point on a missed field goal help that?

Time will tell.

And maybe stuck in the mud, resistant-to-change curmudgeons like myself have to be open to give the new game a chance. It’s true, I am often reticent to change.

For example, even though I enjoyed this year’s Riley Green performance, I would rather the Grey Cup halftime show feature Canadian artists. Green, afterall, didn’t even post to his X or Instagram platforms that he was performing at the Calgary party Sunday. And in my previous column, I wrote about giving the Leafs, from the president to GM to coach and GM, the full season to work out of their hole instead of bringing in someone like former mayor and CFL commissioner John Tory as president and legendary John Tortorella as coach.

While I like those guys, I also think it’s only fair to give the new regime of Keith Pelley, John Chayka and Jim Hiller a full chance. So maybe that should apply to what Johnston is trying to do. Some polls show Argos fans are open to doing that. But not my friends who love the CFL. They don’t want these changes. The bigger worry is, where could all of this lead?

Is this a way of eventually turning the CFL into a minor-league operation to feed the NFL — effectively making the Canadian game cancelled?

Fair question.

The CFL is saying that is not that they are doing and some on the inside seem understandably touchy about anybody suggesting such a thing. That said, those in charge deserve to be given a fair chance to show what they have in mind will help grow the sport and fan interest in it.

However, if the real plan behind the scenes is to phase out the Canadian game in favour of phasing in the sometimes over-coached, unimaginative, 11-player, four-down NFL-style football, count me out.

Things can happen. Who would have ever thought there would be no more Snowbirds? Or Sir John A. Macdonald o n the $10 bill or in statue form in his hometown of Kingston, or Don Cherry on Hockey Night in Canada on CBC? Canadians are very good at cancelling Canadian institutions and legends.

The American game is fine as it is, but the CFL needs to be always remain the Canadian game the same way Canada will never become part of the U.S.

RECOMMENDED VIDEO

Read full story at source