Darian Mensah not a finalist for Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award, and it’s seemingly for a silly reason
· Yahoo Sports
I don’t often opine on the consideration for or decisions regarding individual awards around here, particularly with articles of their own. But I saw something today that I wanted to use my platform to make very clear.
Miami Hurricanes QB Darian Mensah is a top Heisman Trophy finalist. He is the best quarterback in the nation. He leads FBS in completion percentage (76.3%) and QB rating (186.8). He’s thrown for 3076 yards with 29 touchdowns and just two picks, which rank near the top of their respective categories. He’s been elite in every sense of the word.
Visit sportbet.reviews for more information.
That said, he was absent from the list of five finalists for the Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award. And Texas AB Arch Manning (LOL) was one of them.
The Top 5 are here. 🏈💪
— Golden Arm Award (@GoldenArmAward) November 20, 2026
CJ Carr, Notre Dame
Devon Dampier, Utah
Arch Manning, Texas
Drew Mestemaker, Oklahoma State
Gunner Stockton, Georgia
Who’s taking home the 2026 Jonny Unitas Golden Arm Award presented by @AOSmithHotWater? 👇 #GoldenArmAwardpic.twitter.com/ROitlTELhj
As far as why he was excluded, the award lists among its criteria that no player shall have played for more than two programs, subject to “committee review in exceptional circumstances.”
Well, that’s funny. Cam Ward was a finalist two years ago, and he played for more than two programs. Yeah, I don’t care if one was FCS. It doesn’t matter. He played for more than two programs, which makes this whole thing seem stupid and arbitrary. It appears as though the award powers-that-be have a “holier than thou” attitude when it comes to “commitment & loyalty” of a player.
My problem is two-fold. First, Miami has proven that the transfer portal is a good thing, particularly at quarterback, and that players can find the best versions of themselves as players and teammates at a third school. Ward proved it. Carson Beck showed it last year in his second stop. And Mensah is an elite leader, quarterback and teammate at stop number three.
That’s the transfer portal world that we live in nowadays, and it’s the portal world at its finest in Coral Gables. Putting in a transfer limitation requirement while promoting commitment/loyalty/positive impact elsewhere creates an inference that these players do not possess it, and frankly, that’s the wrong message to send.
But the message I want to make sure that voters for the Heisman Trophy, Maxwell Award, and other individual awards realize is: MENSAH DID NOT QUALIFY. I write this because sometimes you will see some players win the Unitas or Maxwell Award and go on to win the Heisman Trophy. NOT WINNING THE UNITAS AWARD DOES NOT MEAN MENSAH IS/WAS NOT THE BEST QB THIS YEAR. IT MEANS HE DID NOT MEET THE COMMITTEE’S PRETTY LITTLE CRITERIA REGARDING SUPPOSED LOYALTY THAT HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH HOW GREAT HE DID ON THE FIELD AND AS A TEAMMATE AND LEADER.
There. Just so we have that clear.
With that being said, #HeisMensah hype will continue on Saturday morning in Coral Gables, where ESPN College Gameday is taking place.