'He shouldn't be here': Nasser Hussain slams Pakistan for picking Saim Ayub as opener scores consecutive ducks in 3rd Test at Edgbaston

· Yahoo Sports

'He shouldn't be here': Nasser Hussain slams Pakistan for picking Saim Ayub as opener scores consecutive ducks in 3rd Test at Edgbaston originally appeared on Cricket News. Add Cricket News as a Preferred Source by clicking here.

KEY TAKEAWAYS:

  • Pakistan recalled Saim Ayub from CPL mid-tournament, but he scored two ducks in his first Test back after an 8-month gap.
  • England dominate with Ollie Robinson’s first-ball wickets.
  •  Ex-captain Nasser Hussain calls selection “a gamble gone wrong” and questions PCB’s cricketing logic.

7,000 km for a pair of ducks! Nasser Hussain blames chaotic PCB management for Saim Ayub's Edgbaston nightmare against England

Pakistan's batting horror show in England just found a new low point, and Saim Ayub's whirlwind week from the Caribbean to Birmingham has become a headline.

Visit moryak.biz for more information.

After being called into a hastily reshuffled squad and thrust straight into the top order at Edgbaston, Ayub walked away with a pair of ducks in the two innings and a fair bit of criticism from former England captain Nasser Hussain to go with it.

Joe Root's side, already sitting pretty at 2-0 up in the series, piled on the pressure by getting bowled out for 453 on day two, banking a first-innings lead of 320 runs. That kind of cushion against a side already rattled meant England were suddenly eyeing a quick finish rather than a grind.

Ollie Robinson got his fourth first-ball dismissal in just 13 spells this series, and this particular one came as part of a double-wicket maiden that left Pakistan staring down an almost impossible deficit.

By the time rain forced an early stop around 5:30 pm, Pakistan had slumped to 52 for 2, still 268 runs adrift, with Robinson boasting figures of 2 for 10 off six overs, three of them maidens.

MORE: 'It's depressing': Pakistan's batting hits new low as Saud Shakeel concedes team 'not used to facing' conditions in England

Why Saim Ayub's Edgbaston call-up raised eyebrows

Ayub wasn’t even in England when Pakistan named their squad. He was out there, under a Caribbean sky, playing for Jamaica Kingsmen in the CPL. He had smashed a rapid 102 off 58 balls to fire Jamaica Kingsmen to victory in the CPL.

Two days later, while England were dismantling Pakistan in the second Test, Ayub had just touched down in Trinidad, wrapping up another comfortable win for his franchise.

Fast forward barely a week, and he was standing in a jumper under grey Birmingham skies. He was among the seven reinforcements flown in following PCB's chaotic overhaul after the Lord's collapse.

While CPL cricket is hardly ideal preparation for Test conditions in England, Ayub was still the most seasoned of the new arrivals by some distance. Between the seven players drafted in, they'd combined for just ten Test caps, eight of which belong to Ayub alone.

MORE: Former Pakistan WK Rashid Latif makes 'Indian agent' remark against head coach Mike Hesson

Hussain didn't hold back after watching Ayub fall twice without scoring.

"The truth is he shouldn't be here. He came from the CPL and hasn't played first-class cricket in some time," Hussain told as an expert for Sky Sports.

"I don't know who thinks it's the right thing to fly someone over from foreign conditions, and think they'll be fine in these conditions against a Dukes ball and Ollie Robinson."

MORE: Pakistan cricket team mistaken for asylum seekers by masked protesters in Portsmouth

Hussain's criticism is fair, but points to a deeper problem

Hussain is spot on, and honestly, it's hard to argue with the logic. If the PCB expects a batter to jump from T20 franchise cricket in the Caribbean straight into a Test match against the Dukes ball, English conditions and a bowler in the kind of form Robinson's showing, the board is setting them up to fail.

MORE: 'Disgraceful, worst Pakistan team': Fans express frustration as Babar Azam and Co. stare at embarrassing whitewash in England

Ayub hadn't played first-class cricket since October 2025; that's not a preparation gap, that's a chasm. But the real issue isn't really about Ayub as a player. It's about a board that panicked so badly after Lord's that it ended up prioritising experience on paper over actual readiness for the conditions in front of them.

Eight Test caps sound decent until you realise none of that experience translates from CPL pitches to a seaming Edgbaston surface. Pakistan's collapse here isn't one man's failure; it's the predictable result of chaotic, reactive selection dressed up as a solution.

For all the latest cricket news, opinion, and commentary, and to share your voice, head to our Facebook, Instagram, and X (Twitter) pages.

Read full story at source